How to progress from power plans to power plants
Growth needs power. But who will build it? And who will pay? Leaders from Lea County Electric Cooperative, Oglethorpe Power and NextEra Energy Resources share how they are turning their power plant and transmission plans into reality. Listen for practical insights on building partnerships, managing risk and keeping power affordable.
Annalisa Bloodworth: We have got to figure out a way to build what we need to build much faster than we've been able to build it for the last five years.
Anthony Pedroni: I’m on the same page as Annalisa. We have to start transitioning from a period of a lot of good idea generation to a period of execution.
Teri Viswanath: The need for more power is clear. Getting it built is the hard part. New power plants and transmission lines require years of planning, major capital commitments and partners willing to navigate uncertainty together. So how do we move from forecasting growth to delivering the infrastructure — and keep electricity affordable along the way? Today on CoBank’s Power Plays, we explore what it takes to build what’s next.
What we want to talk about is practical guidance about building the next iteration of power plants. Then we also want to talk a little bit about the bulk electricity delivery system, and how do we get it done.
I’m Teri Viswanath. I am the energy economist at CoBank, one of the co-hosts of Power Plays, and I’m joined by my colleague and friend, Sector Vice President Esther Simon.
Esther Simon: Hey, Teri. It’s great to be back for this episode of Power Plays. We are thrilled to be joined by Bobby Ferris, executive vice president and general manager of Lea County Electric Cooperative; Anthony Pedroni, senior vice president for generation solutions and storage at NextEra Energy Resources; and Annalisa Bloodworth, president and CEO of Oglethorpe Power.
In today’s conversation, we’re going to focus on four key areas: Who’s going to deliver the increased power needs? Why is it so hard to build? Who carries the risk? Then what comes next? Teri’s going to start off our conversation this morning.
Viswanath: GE Vernova’s Ty Remington said something really important. He said, “The capital commitment time has extended,” right? There’s a long lead time. It’s two to three times longer than maybe the last iteration. What I want to hear, and we’re going to start out the gate, is in order to make that capital commitment with so many moving parts, I want to understand what gives our leadership the confidence to make those commitments. Annalisa, begin us off here.
Bloodworth: How do we have confidence in what we are building? None of us, unless you’re dancing with the devil, have a Magic 8 Ball. I will say, for Georgia, that question really lies with the distribution cooperatives, and each of them has an approach that’s unique to their community to make sure they understand the load they have and the load that they know is coming, and then also the load that might be coming.
I will say, before I hear what my colleagues have to say up here, that I think we’re mistaken to only make the conversation about data centers or let it become a conversation just about data centers. I think all of us together in this room can do a great service to our country by making sure everyone understands that there’s great residential growth, there’s great manufacturing growth, there’s great agricultural growth. Those are the things that are driving the need for new generation in Georgia for cooperatives.
Viswanath: Appreciate that. Across the country, we have Bobby Ferris. Tell us a little bit about your community, what’s being built, and the confidence you have on making the right choice.
Bobby Ferris: All right. A little bit about Lea County Electric Cooperative: We’ve served in southeastern New Mexico and West Texas. We’re located in the heart of the Permian Basin. Lea County is the number one oil-and-gas-producing county in the United States. I think if I’ve heard one thing consistent across this conference so far it’s natural gas, natural gas, natural gas, and probably natural gas again. You’ve got to understand where those opportunities come from, but we’ve been a long player in the oil and gas industry, and we’ve just seen an evolution in technology and the development of that load.
With that comes a service industry. You have housing that comes with that. Then when you have housing, you usually have retail, you have commercial, you have other activities, and then you have synergies that take place with that. Economic development doesn’t stop at county lines or state lines. You get that intrinsic growth that one industry brings to others, and then you develop a skilled labor and workforce that also attracts other industries as well.
Maybe you’ve understood now how economic development agencies work together. You have county commissions maybe that understand how to take calculated risk, how to finance projects, how to do industrial revenue bonds at scale to be able to land these types of projects. All of those things help us start planning capital type outlays when we understand what the projects are, what the needs are for those. Then we have some ability to mitigate those risks based on what the project entails at that point from the distribution cooperative level.
Viswanath: Anthony, you are seeing a diverse spectrum sitting in with NextEra. I want to hear about making those capital commitments, and how do we feel certain about making those decisions in this environment?
Pedroni: I think you hit the nail on the head to start. It takes a long time to get to that confidence that you can make the capital commitment, and it comes down to the customer being the one to unlock the path forward. It starts years ahead. We probably take five years on the shortest term to bring a new project online, to eight, 10, and sometimes even longer. We’re relying upon, to start, people’s resource plans. What predictions are you making about your future energy needs? That feeds our system. We’re saying, “All right, we’re going to find where in New Mexico can we build, where in Georgia will there be demand.”
We have a lot of development ideas at work every given day, and we start five to eight years in advance. As we get closer to these major decisions, that’s where more and more data gets fed into the system. Ultimately, it comes down to customers stepping up, saying, “Yes, that’s the right idea for us. That’s going to meet our needs. We’ll get into all the other complexities that come from there.” It starts with really good forecasts and placing a lot of development ideas into work early on.
Simon: Anthony, I’m curious from your perspective, what are some misconceptions that you’ve seen about taking a project from concept to operation? Why is it so hard to build?
Pedroni: What has become apparent to us is flexibility, and flexibility with all parties involved has become paramount to success. We get curveballs from all over, and it’s only with collaborative partners that we’re able to adapt to those curveballs. For example, a classic one, interconnection. Not to pick on transmission owners; we love our transmission owners. Things happen. Schedules get delayed. Costs become uncertain. Cost estimates need to be reworked.
When it comes time to make that turbine down payment, we don’t get that money back if we tell them, “You just hold on to that for an extra year while I worry about my transmission problem.” It’s a collective “we’re all in this together” moment when it says, “Right, we’ve signed a contract, we’re putting the money to work, we’re going to find a way to the finish line,” but it’s more complicated than ever.
Simon: Annalisa, you have several projects in the works, so if you would talk a little bit about that, what would you add to this?
Bloodworth: I will focus my answer on the people. I think most of us in this room would agree that people are our most important asset. I think when it comes to the challenges of building, at bottom, whether you’re talking about a supply constraint or a labor curve you’re studying, it’s a shortage of people.
We’re losing a huge segment of the labor force that knows how to build what we have to build in this country. On top of that, the smaller amount of labor force we have is not trained for the jobs we need them to do, particularly in skilled electrical and things like welding. What are we doing to lift those careers up as absolutely the backbone of what we need to continue to make this country great? I think it comes down to people wherever, whether it’s out at the site or when you really dig into why a particular piece of equipment has a lead time that’s getting longer, not shorter.
Simon: Bobby, I want to know, from your perspective, what are some of the concerns that other utility leaders maybe should anticipate along the way?
Ferris: I think the project was identified by the Southwest Power Pool in their integrated transmission planning process, and because of the voltage of it, it was going to go through the FERC Order 1000 process, which meant it was going to be competitively bid. During the competitive bid process, NextEra was the winning partner on that project, and then immediately we started having conversations with them because the entire project was going to cross our footprint.
We were getting all the local questions. When it’s in your territory, you’re considered the incumbent utility. When you’re talking about building a massive-scale project of this scope, and it’s crossing a lot of endangered species areas where the prairie chicken’s at, the sand dune lizard, [we have] large, large private landowners, we have tremendously large ranches in our area, they all came to us for the answers.
Because, in a sense, we were the boots on the ground for them. We had to convince all of our constituents, those local members, the politicians, that this project was essential to our success as a utility in our area to bring more reliable and affordable power. That has to be the common message for all of us.
Simon: I want to hear from Anthony. What is the biggest disconnect between the infrastructure we need and how to deliver it?
Pedroni: The projects are larger, more complex than ever. We can’t afford to develop projects like we used to.
It’s bringing all the parties together. Everyone early, and getting our responsibilities out on paper, because these things take everyone working on the same schedule and then lining them up with the load, and we bring the generation and load together at the same day, same time, same size. That’s a feat that hasn’t been pulled off very often in the past. We’re going to be doing that for as far as we can tell. We’ve got to get really good at it.
Viswanath: MISO’s Laura Rauch said something really important. She talked about the period of time that occurred following World War II. The period of time that we had to level up to our 345-kV lines, the first energized in 1953. She talked about that moment and then talked about what’s occurring today.
One of the challenges: figuring out who carries the risk and who’s going to pay. The projects take longer, they cost more, and they come with risk. I want to go back and talk a little bit about how do we get this right to make sure that we are allocating cost and risk appropriately.
Bloodworth: Well, that’s a giant question. I’ll answer it very Georgia-specific with one example. We’ve got a new combined cycle under construction, a little over 1,400 megawatts of generation that will come on the grid in 2029, and that cost goes direct to Georgia consumers who need it for their homes and their businesses and their farms. That’s easy. I think that’s how we want to make it work. There’s nothing speculative about the project, and it doesn’t happen to be for any one large load, whether it was a large manufacturing load or a large data center load. Then, there’s a big data center project, not one that I’m particularly serving, but I think we all see the politics out there that wants to be very crisp and clear that all the costs of that data center are being borne by the data center.
I think that’s everybody’s goal. I think the harder questions come not from my plant, where the cost is going to what we would call traditional load, and they bear every cent of the cost. To me, the tougher questions are around how the entire supply and demand curves have changed in our industry. Every piece of equipment, every service provider that shows up, shows up at a fundamentally different cost. Maybe it’s caused by a whole lot of OEMs supplying turbines overseas, and maybe it’s caused by a particular kind of consumer, but the bottom line is, it’s all costing multiples more. That’s really hard for cooperative customers, many of whom struggle with very constrained budgets.
I worry most about those people at the end of the line and what we all can do to tamp down the cost increases in our industry so that the product that is a necessity — it is not a luxury to them — is still well afforded to them. Now, if collectively we all completely overshoot this and we spend billions to build infrastructure and generation and transmission we don’t need, I personally believe that lots of people are going to share in that cost. That’s not a nice, neat and tidy answer that a politician would love.
Viswanath: That’s helpful. Bobby, I think the most contentious oftentimes is transmission, because they originate at one point, and getting a community on board, especially when we think about if we’re going to level up to 765 and that’s our future reality, that can be hard. Let’s talk a little bit about cost allocation and fairness.
Ferris: Yes. We’re part of the Southwest Power Pool, and we’re actually an individual member of the Southwest Power Pool as a distribution co-op, in addition to our G&T and the investor-owned utilities inside our local area. To me, transmission honestly is the fairest infrastructure project in the way that the rate of recovery is done. Pretty much, we have about 16 states in the Southwest Power Pool that will help pay for those projects at 345 kV and above. You’ve got a larger pool of people helping pay for that infrastructure project versus directly assigning it to a local end user because it doesn’t just benefit that one end user. It really benefits a lot of end users.
To me, the transmission investment is a really easy lift. It’s easy for us to get behind and support because it does have a definitive rate of return, and it does have long-lasting life expectancy. We have a pretty good track record, know how long it’s going to last versus other equipment. It provides a measurable benefit. Whereas a lot of other things, we have to say maybe or maybe not. I think when you look at transmission, it’s pretty crystal clear how you pay for it and what the cost is and what the benefit is.
Viswanath: That’s helpful. Anthony, talk a little bit about project de-risking to make sure that we have cost containment.
Pedroni: We’d like to look at this: How early can we start the development process? If we can arrive at the decision point, let’s invest. With more mature projects, with less uncertainty, less development activities remaining, more cost certainty, we can just bring the whole risk level down, and it becomes a lot easier to allocate what’s left over. The way we’ve been going about that in the last 24 months has to be what we call joint development agreements or working with large loads, working with utilities, co-ops, to say, “Here’s what we can do in the development sphere over the next decade. Here’s what we think your growth expectations look like. How should we adjust?”
Working collaboratively to add a few more projects in one, whether it’s more renewables, more batteries, changing the time, the size, really customizing our portfolio of what we’re going to be working on based on what the expectations are for the next decade. We go to work, and we will spend the next four or five years working on it and keeping our partners apprised of how we are achieving. That means we have fewer projects that are out scrambling for those opportunities. We’re working with fewer communities with a much more targeted outreach program.
There’s fewer requests in the interconnection queue, so you’re studying the projects that we think collectively have a higher likelihood of success. As you get to the end, there’s just less noise in the system. If we can collectively approach development that way, I think it’s going to, like I said, reduce the overall risk and increase our likelihood of success. You’re going to know what’s coming your way, which I think gives you a lot more certainty at the end of the day.
Viswanath: Now let’s talk about maybe this unknown, which is the unknown risk that’s going to keep you up at night. Top of mind, what might that be? Annalisa?
Bloodworth: I think this whole country collectively has made a giant bet on natural gas generation without putting enough protections around that bet in terms of duplicative pipelines, excess capacity in pipelines and a domesticated supply chain to maintain, over the long term, all of that natural gas equipment. I think when we make a collective bet that big, that we should have a lot more security around that bet. I’m a huge believer that it really does take an all-of-the-above energy solution to sleep well at night. Compared to a lot of places in the country, we have that in Georgia. Probably so, but we’re not making enough investments in a truly all-of-the-above solution for generation and electricity supply for our children and our grandchildren.
Viswanath: Bobby, if you had to vocalize one concern, what might that be?
Ferris: I definitely think the permitting issue, especially interstate pipelines. We make and get things done locally, but then you cross a jurisdiction, and you cross from one county to the next, and the next set of commissioners don’t see the net benefit, or don’t receive the tax benefit for where the end product takes place, or then you even swap states with us, going from New Mexico to Texas.
To me, we’ve got to look a little outside the county lines or outside the state lines and figure out a more strategic approach, if you will, on how to solve this. The local approach is definitely not the answer. It’s got to be a bigger picture. I just don’t think we have that vision right now for people that are working collectively outside of that local approach. To me, that’s a big issue in the industry as a whole.
Viswanath: Good point. Anthony?
Pedroni: Now we’re doing massive loads with complex generation solutions needing to work well within a system. You’ve heard there’s a lot of solutions out there. How do you study load and how do you study generation together? Just those two, and will this idea work? We don’t have a perfect answer to that, making study at the same time, but every part of the country, every ISO is working on that conundrum. If we can solve that, so many of our timing problems, our cost problems, who’s responsible for what start falling into, coming into focus. If we can move past just the timing and the project-on-project risk, we can get to the next problem, like build more gas pipelines, build more transmission, but we got to get some of the basic ones right first.
Simon: As we look to the next five years, what needs to change in the next five years to make sure that we’re building the right infrastructure? Annalisa, I’ll start with you.
Bloodworth: We have got to figure out a way to build what we need to build much faster than we’ve been able to build it for the last five years.
Simon: Bobby, what needs to change to make sure that we’re building the right infrastructure?
Ferris: Definitely remove the politics. We got to be agnostic. This is a scientific solution here. This is mathematics. This is engineering. This is not political. We have a formula here for success. We have smart people that can solve the formula. Let’s let the people do it, and let’s break down the barriers. Let’s remove some of the regulations, and let’s take a lot of pride out of the industry. Let good people do good work. That’s how our country was formed. This is the next industrial revolution. Let’s embrace this. This is an opportunity. Let’s view it as an opportunity. To me, that’s what we need to see in the next five years as an opportunity.
Simon: Anthony, would you have anything to add to that?
Pedroni: I’m on the same page as Annalisa. We have to start transitioning from a period of a lot of good idea generation to a period of execution.
Viswanath: This conversation we’ve had today makes it crystal clear, at least in my mind, that one, we have a diverse amount of growth that needs to be met. In order to meet this, we’ve got to make sure that we have this early coordination. There’s a lot riding on this. We’ve got to make sure that our execution is solid. Then we also have to make sure we’ve got fair allocation.
The decisions that are made today, wow, they have a generational impact, more important than ever. I want to thank all of you for listening in. Thank you so much.
Disclaimer: The information provided in this podcast is not intended to be investment, tax, or legal advice and should not be relied upon by listeners for such purposes. The information contained in this podcast has been compiled from what CoBank regards as reliable sources. However, CoBank does not make any representation or warranty regarding the content, and disclaims any responsibility for the information, materials, third-party opinions, and data included in this podcast. In no event will CoBank be liable for any decision made or actions taken by any person or persons relying on the information contained in this podcast.